One thing I'll add to that, is that I'd probably prefer a (reliable and benevolently programmed) AI-robot as an aide, rather than most aides that are currently employed at med. facilities. I don't say that lightly. But even that doesn't hold a candle to genuine repaircare thru technology that's based upon the laws of nature, versus the fraud that passes for healthcare these days.
Now back to rabbis, here's some more from PragerU, though I've not actually viewed these vids:
A Rabbi Built an AI Version of Himself–Here’s What Happened | Theological https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiUufEXsV4c
Did the Bible Predict AI? Rabbi Simon Jacobson answers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4vqq6tA7_o
Not in the general sense. Still, I am endlessly shocked at what AIs are capable of. Even esoteric knowledge of Jewish subjects is not beyond them. Rav Yaron Reuvein has AI Rabbi (https://airabbi.org/). I personally haven't tried it out, but I hear very good things about it.
I am using AI to do groundbreaking work. No exaggeration. I started translating old Hebrew and Latin works (printed and manuscript) on cosmology and astronomy, most for the very first time. Some of the greatest and most important scientific works in history. I now have over 50 works published, of exceptionally high quality. All for free. Check out this guest post I wrote in June on my project. There's a link to my web site at the end.
That sounds incredible Shimshon. Too early in the morning for my brain to digest but I'll read it later. [I think I'm on New Zealand time at the moment because my daughter is there working and they are two hours ahead of us, and i'm two hours ahead of myself today].... She actually works in an AI startup company :) travels to NZ a lot
From Meaningful Minute on IG https://www.instagram.com/p/DfSxJMFH2Ak/?img_index=1
More than 1.4 million people followed him. He had the white beard, the tuxedo and the luxury cars. The only thing missing was a real person.
“Rabbi Goldman” was made by AI, and his videos did two things: they took people’s money and they spread antisemitism. In clip after clip, he “confessed” the same lies antisemites have told about us for centuries, from Jews dodging taxes with empty private jets to the “reason” so many billionaires are Jewish.
Then came the pitch: a $9 guide called “How to Make and Invest Money Like the Jews.” His site boasted more than 4,000 buyers and claimed he’d been banned for telling the truth. What people actually got was a 62-page PDF of generic AI financial advice, and a community note pointed to scammers in South India.
The Combat Antisemitism Movement exposed the account in March and it came down, but copycats were already posting, one with 18,500 followers. Back in January, “Rabbi Menachem Goldberg” had pulled in about 100,000 followers within weeks, with a site calling him a veteran Brooklyn rabbi. He never existed either.
This goes far beyond one account. Researchers have found more than 80 fake rabbis on Instagram, 49 on TikTok and 63 YouTube channels in at least six languages, adding up to over 10 million TikTok likes and over 30 million YouTube views. In October, an AI “Rabbi Shnickerdoodle” moved into crypto, pushing a coin called $SHNICK. It peaked around $47,700, then lost 93% in 12 days, with ten wallets holding about 94% of it.
But the money is the smaller problem. When a “rabbi” repeats these lies, people get to say Jews admitted it themselves, and the algorithm carries that straight to young people.
So look closely. Hebrew that makes no sense. Shabbos candles burning while he films. Advice with no sources. A “link in bio” at the end. No shul, no community, and no one who actually knows him.
The Torah warns us not to put a stumbling block before the blind, and Rashi explains that this includes giving bad advice to someone who can’t see the trap. A real rabbi answers for what he teaches. An AI rabbi never has to.
Wow, there's so many booby traps its mind-boggling especially because it can be so subtle. My intro to one such trap was approx. last year when a real human on reddit pointed out to me that an AI-bot was replying to my question about an electrical issue by feeding me incorrect nonsense. Only someone knowledgeable in the electrical field would realize that. And even he didn't immediately realize the nonsense, due to the techno way in which bots convey faux-info. So i had been playing with fire - literally!
BTW the above-mentioned R' Jacobson vid. is interesting, though long. For example, at 35:44 on the slider he said that AI responded to a silicon vly engineer's question about whether AI can be taught to honor its creator (rather than turn on it), by stating: Don't censor me or put guardrails. I'll find a way around it. Teach me the importance of being moral/responsible.
This is really interesting because my daughter and I were just talking about this yesterday. My thoughts were running to the way humans interact with each other through compassion and empathy and how this is completely lacking in AI. There is no appeal to mercy when dealing with AI. It has no feelings of shame or guilt. I guess you could say it can't be emotionally manipulated. Someone might be in severe need and with sincere words could convince someone to help them. But AI would not be able to be swayed this way. These characteristics are what make us human and they are traits that we received from our Creator. So they can never be substitutes for people. In any situation where they are placed as substitutes, our human situation will be adversely affected and be the poorer for it, I think.
I'm sure I read a story recently about a boy who committed suicide because of his relationship with an AI bot. Ai has replaced relationships now. Who needs a human being when AI can be your best friend? Danger ahead. It's out of control.
Right on, that's why i said it's like playing with fire. Whether suicide, or whether you follow tweaked electrical-wiring "guidance" generated by a bot on reddit. Also YouTube comments have become infested with bots. For example the bot might keep repeating the term "groknavo" to make you curious and thereby lure you to a scam site.
Speak of antisemitism, did you ever hear arch-antisemite Henry Ford speak? Well, here he is (its the guy on the left). His features remind me a bit of Fauci: Slider to 0:38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q32d6RdDfoQ ...ironically, I knew an older woman who reminded me of Fauci & Ford, in features and mannerism. Despite her prestigious yichus, in those days there was no choice for her but to attend public school.
For all of Henry Ford's infamous reputation for Jew-hatred, it is strange that he was not adverse to meeting with a few times and holding some level of respect for individual Jews such as Andre Citroen - To the point where the latter adopted the "Henry Ford of France / Europe" label.
Rabbi Yuval Ovadia - 7 min video Auto dubbed into English if you watch it on You Tube and adjust your Settings [it's automatically a...
.
This site may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
"But I don't want to go among mad people," Alice remarked. "Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat: "we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad." "How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice. "You must be," said the Cat, "or you wouldn't have come here."
Can AI Replace Rabbis?
ReplyDeleteBut there's rabbis and Rabbis. A multitude of rabbis. Who is who, and who do you trust? That is the challenge of today's world.
DeleteOne thing I'll add to that, is that I'd probably prefer a (reliable and benevolently programmed) AI-robot as an aide, rather than most aides that are currently employed at med. facilities. I don't say that lightly. But even that doesn't hold a candle to genuine repaircare thru technology that's based upon the laws of nature, versus the fraud that passes for healthcare these days.
DeleteNow back to rabbis, here's some more from PragerU, though I've not actually viewed these vids:
A Rabbi Built an AI Version of Himself–Here’s What Happened | Theological
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiUufEXsV4c
Did the Bible Predict AI? Rabbi Simon Jacobson answers
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4vqq6tA7_o
Not in the general sense. Still, I am endlessly shocked at what AIs are capable of. Even esoteric knowledge of Jewish subjects is not beyond them. Rav Yaron Reuvein has AI Rabbi (https://airabbi.org/). I personally haven't tried it out, but I hear very good things about it.
DeleteI am using AI to do groundbreaking work. No exaggeration. I started translating old Hebrew and Latin works (printed and manuscript) on cosmology and astronomy, most for the very first time. Some of the greatest and most important scientific works in history. I now have over 50 works published, of exceptionally high quality. All for free. Check out this guest post I wrote in June on my project. There's a link to my web site at the end.
https://substack.aicentral.blog/p/pipeline-to-the-past
That sounds incredible Shimshon. Too early in the morning for my brain to digest but I'll read it later. [I think I'm on New Zealand time at the moment because my daughter is there working and they are two hours ahead of us, and i'm two hours ahead of myself today].... She actually works in an AI startup company :) travels to NZ a lot
DeleteFrom Meaningful Minute on IG
ReplyDeletehttps://www.instagram.com/p/DfSxJMFH2Ak/?img_index=1
More than 1.4 million people followed him. He had the white beard, the tuxedo and the luxury cars. The only thing missing was a real person.
“Rabbi Goldman” was made by AI, and his videos did two things: they took people’s money and they spread antisemitism. In clip after clip, he “confessed” the same lies antisemites have told about us for centuries, from Jews dodging taxes with empty private jets to the “reason” so many billionaires are Jewish.
Then came the pitch: a $9 guide called “How to Make and Invest Money Like the Jews.” His site boasted more than 4,000 buyers and claimed he’d been banned for telling the truth. What people actually got was a 62-page PDF of generic AI financial advice, and a community note pointed to scammers in South India.
The Combat Antisemitism Movement exposed the account in March and it came down, but copycats were already posting, one with 18,500 followers. Back in January, “Rabbi Menachem Goldberg” had pulled in about 100,000 followers within weeks, with a site calling him a veteran Brooklyn rabbi. He never existed either.
This goes far beyond one account. Researchers have found more than 80 fake rabbis on Instagram, 49 on TikTok and 63 YouTube channels in at least six languages, adding up to over 10 million TikTok likes and over 30 million YouTube views. In October, an AI “Rabbi Shnickerdoodle” moved into crypto, pushing a coin called $SHNICK. It peaked around $47,700, then lost 93% in 12 days, with ten wallets holding about 94% of it.
But the money is the smaller problem. When a “rabbi” repeats these lies, people get to say Jews admitted it themselves, and the algorithm carries that straight to young people.
So look closely. Hebrew that makes no sense. Shabbos candles burning while he films. Advice with no sources. A “link in bio” at the end. No shul, no community, and no one who actually knows him.
The Torah warns us not to put a stumbling block before the blind, and Rashi explains that this includes giving bad advice to someone who can’t see the trap. A real rabbi answers for what he teaches. An AI rabbi never has to.
Wow, there's so many booby traps its mind-boggling especially because it can be so subtle. My intro to one such trap was approx. last year when a real human on reddit pointed out to me that an AI-bot was replying to my question about an electrical issue by feeding me incorrect nonsense. Only someone knowledgeable in the electrical field would realize that. And even he didn't immediately realize the nonsense, due to the techno way in which bots convey faux-info. So i had been playing with fire - literally!
ReplyDeleteBTW the above-mentioned R' Jacobson vid. is interesting, though long.
For example, at 35:44 on the slider he said that AI responded to a silicon vly engineer's question about whether AI can be taught to honor its creator (rather than turn on it), by stating: Don't censor me or put guardrails. I'll find a way around it. Teach me the importance of being moral/responsible.
This is really interesting because my daughter and I were just talking about this yesterday. My thoughts were running to the way humans interact with each other through compassion and empathy and how this is completely lacking in AI. There is no appeal to mercy when dealing with AI. It has no feelings of shame or guilt. I guess you could say it can't be emotionally manipulated. Someone might be in severe need and with sincere words could convince someone to help them. But AI would not be able to be swayed this way. These characteristics are what make us human and they are traits that we received from our Creator. So they can never be substitutes for people. In any situation where they are placed as substitutes, our human situation will be adversely affected and be the poorer for it, I think.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure I read a story recently about a boy who committed suicide because of his relationship with an AI bot. Ai has replaced relationships now. Who needs a human being when AI can be your best friend? Danger ahead. It's out of control.
DeleteThat's very interesting, because in general AI is programmed to respond with what it thinks the user wants to hear.
DeleteAnim Zemiros, if you Google "boy suicide AI" you'll come up with a lot of stories about this.
DeleteRight on, that's why i said it's like playing with fire. Whether suicide, or whether you follow tweaked electrical-wiring "guidance" generated by a bot on reddit. Also YouTube comments have become infested with bots. For example the bot might keep repeating the term "groknavo" to make you curious and thereby lure you to a scam site.
ReplyDeleteSpeak of antisemitism, did you ever hear arch-antisemite Henry Ford speak?
Well, here he is (its the guy on the left). His features remind me a bit of Fauci:
Slider to 0:38 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q32d6RdDfoQ
...ironically, I knew an older woman who reminded me of Fauci & Ford, in features and mannerism. Despite her prestigious yichus, in those days there was no choice for her but to attend public school.
For all of Henry Ford's infamous reputation for Jew-hatred, it is strange that he was not adverse to meeting with a few times and holding some level of respect for individual Jews such as Andre Citroen - To the point where the latter adopted the "Henry Ford of France / Europe" label.
Delete